Wondering What to Do
With Canned Pumpkin?
Turn it into Pumpkin Ice Cream

This pumpkin ice cream was made using the following recipe. It is a custard base and requires some cooking.

As soon as the leaves begin to change and the weather is a little cooler, I start thinking about pumpkin pie and all the other foods that lure me into the Fall season. I remember licking a pumpkin ice cream cone a few times in my life. It was usually near a corn maze or pumpkin patch. Now, this flavor is available for a limited time in freezer sections everywhere. But, if I should happen to get a craving for it in the off season, I have no need to worry. All I have to do is get out my ice cream maker and make my own ice cream!

Pumpkin Ice Cream

Use a 2 qt. ice cream maker or cut the recipe in half for smaller machines.


  • 2 cups heavy cream

  • 1 cup whole milk

  • 1 1/8 cups brown sugar

  • 1 1/2 tbsp. corn syrup

  • 1 cup canned pumpkin

  • 1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract

  • 2 tsp cinnamon

  • 2 eggs


In a sauce pan over medium-low heat, stir together cream, milk, pumpkin, sugar, and corn syrup. Lower heat and let simmer, continue to stir occasionally.

In a mixing bowl, beat eggs on medium speed with a hand mixer. Beat until yellow and thick. Add 1 cup of hot cream mixture in a slow stream to the eggs with the mixer on low speed. Pour the egg mixture back into the pot of cream and stir. Add the cinnamon and stir some more until the mixture thickens and coats the back of the spoon. Add the vanilla and stir again. Transfer the mixture to a bowl and place plastic wrap directly on the top of custard. Allow it to cool some, then chill in the refrigerator.

Take the mixture out of the refrigerator and freeze according to the directions of your ice cream maker. Usually takes 25 minutes. Put into containers and freeze until hardened.

Turn this recipe into an ice cream pie for Thanksgiving.

Make a Jack-o-Lantern with this recipe. (Look on the bottom of the spider sundae page for Jack-o-Lantern directions.)

Return from pumpkin ice cream to homemade ice cream recipes page
Return to ice cream freaks home page

Join us on facebook

Featured Recipes

Nutella Ice Cream

Simple yet satisfying to eat any time of the year - Nutella Ice Cream . Just can't get enough!

Mint Oreo Cookies And Cream Ice Cream

Mint Cookies And Cream Ice Cream feels like a refreshing winter dessert and gets me in the mood for the lucky green month of March when we celebrate St. Patrick's Day. I'd feel really lucky if I had a bowl of this right now!

Spaghetti Ice Cream

Do you fancy the romantic and unusual? Spaghetti Ice Cream is both. It's a fun dessert to share with someone you love. Your kids will especially love it too.

We Recommend...

best blender in the world

It's the best blender in the world for making 30 second ice creams, sorbets, and smoothies. Find out what else it can do.

This is how I'm building my website so I can stay home with my kids and "recession proof" our life. Read my story.